Genealogy of the Cherokee Duncan Family

Instructions on how to interpret this information

10Rebecca Jane Duncan. John W. Carter
11Leonidas Philip Duncan. Mary Fleming
11121314Andrew Jackson Duncan
2Martha Duncan. Douglas Bryson
3William Duncan
4Francis Duncan
5Marion Duncan
11122314Elizabeth Jones. John Rattlinggourd, Risingfawn and Henry Blalock
2Frank Jones*
3George Jones*
11124314Edmond Duncan Carey. Lucy Pigeon and Lydia Ann Pigeon
2Mary Ann Carey  Caleb Willis Conner
OK3Ross Thomas Carey. Rebecca Conner, Josephine Blevins and Nannie Henrietta Nidiffer
11125314Jennie Duncan*
2Sarah Elizabeth Duncan*
3Margaret Duncan. Otis J. Wing and Henry Odell
4Barbara Catherine Duncan. William Ferdinand Goodman
11126314Narcissa Jane Duncan. Henry Harrison Scraper
OK2John Hamilton Duncan
11127314Alice Duncan
11129314Bluford Alberty Duncan. Samantha Carter nee Lane
2Rebecca Jane Duncan. Francis Marion Conner
111210314Daniel Duncan* Angeline Daniel
2Dorcas Duncan  Theodore Thomas Kelly
3Rebecca Duncan   Zeno Cox and John B. Lawrence
111211314William Martin*
2Charlotte Martin*
OK3Nathaniel Breckenridge Weir. Mary Elvina Pitcher
4Henry Hickox. Mariammne Connelly
5Annie Hickox. Dr. Albert Harvey Collins
111212314William Duncan*
2Laura Duncan. Job Beaver Parker
11221314Mary McLaughlin. Samuel Martin and George W. Hughes
2John McLaughlin
OK3Ezekial Collin McLaughlin. Susie Harkins and Ellen J. Harkins
4Jennie McLaughlin  Ellis McDaniel
5David McLaughlin  Frances Reynolds



Starr, Emmett. History of the Cherokee Indians and Their Legends and Folk Lore. Oklahoma City, Oklahoma: The Warden Company. 1921

Search Military Records - Fold3

3 thoughts on “Genealogy of the Cherokee Duncan Family”


    I am trying to research Narcissa Duncan Carey. She is listed as Edmund Benge Duncan’s daughter, but , if the birthdates are correct, he would have only been 11 when she was born in 1795. Any chance she was adopted into Edmund & Mary’s family? Could her father possibly be Bob Benge?
    She appears to be my 3rd great grandmother, as the mother of Sarah Ann (Carey) Hicks, who is my maternal grandfather’s ( Sherman Hicks) grandmother.
    Thank you very much. Any help you can give me is greatly appreciated!

    Moniece Charlton

  2. Michelle Deal, Proctor, Petty

    I’m trying to find information on my Great Grandmother who raised me several years of my life after my mother Sylvia Jean Proctor Deal Watson decided she didn’t want me. My Great Grandmothers name was Mary Angie Duncan and resided in Nashville, TN . I was later taken from her and adopted by an “Uncle” Billy Wayne Proctor also from Nashville, TN because of her failing health. My mother passed away in her 20’s I was told due to a car wreck. I am just trying to find out who I am, the uncle and his wife Wanda Gail Lawrence would not give me any information on my family and I’m not even sure that who I was told was my father really was. If anyone can help me I would be greatful I feel so lost in this world, I called my Great Grand Mother Momma Waggoner and she was my mother, she may not have given birth to me but she’s the o e who I claim as was my Mom. Bulaimajean Waggoner was a great aunt who helped Momma Waggoner I called her Aunt Jean and she married A Mr. James T Owens and had one son Rick Owens. Any help is appreciated. My email is

  3. First visit here, but need to make a correction. Dorcas Benge’s maiden name was Lightfoot. She was the daughter of Cap. John Lightfoot and GaHoGah, of the Deer Clan. The sister of Dorcas was Nancy who married a Foster before marrying Adair. Dorcas and Nancy were half-blood Cherokee. The unknown Benge who first married Dorcas was either Trader John Benge or his son “Chief” Robert Benge. Don Shadburn in the book “Upon Our Ruins” makes the statement that it is believed Trader John was the father of Edmund Benge (who later took the name Duncan). There is also some controversy about who the parents of Trader John were, as I have seen on at least one site where his mother was called Ann and was a full blood Cherokee. That said, Please correct me if you know otherwise.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Pin It on Pinterest

Scroll to Top