| Surname | Name | Date and Manner of Reception | When and How Dismissed |
| Skeels | Rev. Thomas | Dec. 25, 1783 | Died, 1792 |
| Sherman | George | . | Excluded, June, 1786 |
| Baker | Joseph | . | Excluded, Dec. 16, 1784 |
| Sherman | George, Jr. | . | Died. |
| Lee | Nathan | . | Excluded, June, 1786 |
| Tower | Joseph | .. | Died |
| Lee | Nathan | . | Letter, Jan. 27, 1791 |
| Collins | John | . | . |
| Cole | James | . | Excluded, June 25, 1789 |
| Mason | Nathaniel | . | Died, May, 1835 |
| Mason | Isaiah | .. | Died, June, 1830 |
| Baker | John | .. | Excluded, Jan. 25, 1787 |
| Baker | Reuben | .. | Letter, Oct. 31, 1793 |
| Carr | Hezekiah | . | Letter, May 26, 1799 |
| Carpenter | Cephas | . | Letter, May 21, 1821 |
| Newton | Samuel | . | Excluded, Nov. 30, 1815 |
| Martin | James | . | Excluded, 1822 |
| Obrian | Thomas | . | Letter, Aug. 29, 1795 |
| Roberts | Lemuel | . | Letter, Aug. 28, 1790 |
| Colvin | Rufus | . | . |
| Davis | David | . | Letter, Nov. 25, 1835 |
| Allen | Benjamin | . | . |
| Bailey | Sarah | . | . |
| Collins | Lydia | . | .. |
| Tower | Elenor | . | Died, Nov. 30, 1872 |
| Sherman | Chloe | . | . |
| Carpenter | Phebe | . | . |
| Lee | Sarah | . | Letter, Jan. 27, 1791 |
| Bailey | Hannah | . | . |
| Collins | Rebekah | . | Excluded, Jan. 29, 1789 |
| Collins | Amy | . | . |
| Cole | Elizabeth | . | Excluded, Mar. 25, 1790 |
| Carr | Eunice | . | Letter, June 12, 1822 |
| Newton | Sarah | . | Letter, 1835 |
| Roberts | Sarah | . | Letter, Oct. 28, 1790 |
| Colvin | Diadama | . | . |
| Carr | Anna | . | . |
| Martin | Freelove | . | Excluded, Mar. 18, 1819 |
| Roberts | Elizabeth | . | . |
| Baker | Abagail | .. | Letter, June 25, 1799 |
| Herrick | Mary | . | . |
| Tower | Lucy | . | Excluded, Jan. 18, 1809 |
| Brown | Amasa | Letter, Feb. 17, 1786 | Letter, Feb. 26, 1789 |
| Howard | Rachel | Profession of Faith, Mar. 27, 1787 | . |
| Baker | Lydia | Letter Sept. 27, 1787 | Letter, Oct. 31, 1795 |
| Allen | Amy | Letter, June 25, 1788 | . |
| Tower | Nathaniel | Profession of Faith, Nov. 27, 1788 | Letter, Feb. 26, 1789 |
| Martin | Thomas | Baptism, Apr. 24, 1788 | Excluded, Oct. 10, 1821 |
| Carr | Benjamin | Baptism, Apr. 24, 1788 | Letter, May 31, 1821 |
| Davis | John, Jr. | Baptism, Apr. 24, 1788 | |
| Collins | Nathan | Baptism, Apr. 24, 1788 | Letter, Mar. 3, 1832 |
| Collins | Nathan Mrs. | Not Recorded (About 1788.) | Letter, Mar. 3, 1832 |
| Skeels | Elijah | Not Recorded (About 1788.) | . |
| Wetmore | Samuel | Not Recorded (About 1788.) | Died, Sept. 1832 |
| Collins | Joseph | Not Recorded (About 1788.) | Died |
| Whipple | Samuel | Not Recorded (About 1788.) | . |
| Parker | Peter | Not Recorded (About 1788.) | Excluded, Dec. 17, 1807 |
| Horton | Hezekiah | Not Recorded (About 1788.) | Died, Jan. 1835 |
| Hix | Hannah | Letter, Mar. 26, 1789 | . |
| Herrick | Polly | Profession of Faith, Feb. 9, 1789 | . |
| Bates | Rufus | Letter, Sept. 30, 1790 | . |
| Hix | Asa | Letter, Oct. 28, 1790 | . |
| Blake | Waitstill | Letter, Oct. 28, 1790 | . |
| Davies | John | Profession of Faith, Dec. 30, 1790 | . |
| Franklin | Sister | Profession of Faith, June 25, 1790 | . |
| Davies | Mary | Profession of Faith, Dec. 30, 1790 | . |
| Bates | Rebekah | Not Recorded (About 1790.) | . |
| Collins | Hezekiah | Not Recorded (About 1790.) | . |
| Royce | Abagail | Not Recorded (About 1790.) | . |
| Westcut | Susanna | Not Recorded (About 1790.) | . |
| Skeels | Mercy | Not Recorded (About 1790.) | . |
| Horton | Renew | Not Recorded (About 1790.) | . |
| Theil | Mercy | Profession of Faith, July 25, 1793 | . |
| Wilmarth | Nathaniel | Letter, Oct. 27, 1794 | Died, Feb. 1839 |
