| Name of Rectors | Elected | Resigned |
| The Rev. WILLIAM SHAW DAVID MALCOLM GEORGE PIGOT ALEXANDER MALCOLM PETER BOURS JOSHUA WINGATE WEEKS THOMAS FITCH OLIVER WILLIAM HARRIS JAMES BOWERS JOHN P. K. HENSHAW JOSEPH R.ANDREWS BENJ.BOSWORTH SMITH THOMAS W. MOTT JOSEPH H. PRICE GEO. C. V. EASTMAN WILLIAM H. LEWIS JOHN P. ROBINSON MOSES P. STICKNEY NICHOLAS P. TILLINGHAST EDWARD BALLARD JOHN B. RICHMOND EDWIN BAILEY CHASE WM. REED WOODBRIDGE | 1717 1719 1727 1740 1753 1763 1786 1791 1802 1813 1816 1818 1825 1831 1832 1833 1840 1842 1847 1848 1851 1860 1867 | 1718 1727* 1735 1749 1762** 1776 1791 1802 1812 1813*** 1816 1819**** 1827 1832 1833 1840 1842 1847 1847 1851 1859 1866 1871 |
The church edifice was erecLed in 1714, enlarged in 1729, and remodeled in 1832.
A subscription of £416 was made in 1707 towards building a church edifice.
*Afterwards removed to Virginia, and married Gen. Washington to Mrs. Curtis.
**Died in Office.
***Afterwards Bishop of Rhode Island.
****Now Bishop of Kentucky, and Presiding or Senior Bishop of the United States.