| Surname | Name | Date and Manner of Reception | When and How Dismissed |
| Collins | Mary | Baptism, Feb. 6, 1858 | . |
| Mason (No.2) | Leonard F. | Baptism, Mar. 14, 1858 | Died, Dec. 25, 1884 |
| Curtis | Betsey | Baptism, Mar. 14, 1858 | Died, Dec. 30, 1867 |
| Fish | Felicia | Baptism, Mar. 14, 1858 | . |
| Rogers | Sabrina W. | Baptism, Mar. 14, 1858 | Letter, May 28, 1884 |
| Casaden | Frank | Baptism, Mar. 14, 1858 | . |
| Curtis | Martin W. | Baptism, Mar. 14, 1858 | Died, Sept. 25, 1894 |
| Wilkinson | Sabery | Baptism, Mar. 14, 1858 | . |
| Tower, Jr. (No.2) | Joseph | Baptism, Mar. 14, 1858 | . |
| Fish | Lester | Baptism, Mar. 14, 1858 | Died, Sept. 14, 1910 |
| Fish | Leonard | Baptism, Mar. 14, 1858 | Died, Jan. 14, 1907 |
| Carrigan | Frank | Baptism, Mar. 14, 1858 | . |
| Fish, Jr. | Enos C. | Baptism, Mar. 14, 1858 | . |
| Rogers | Edwin R. | Baptism, Mar. 14, 1858 | Letter, May 28, 1884 |
| Tower | George | Baptism, Mar. 14, 1858 | . |
| Peters | Henry | Baptism, Mar. 14, 1858 | . |
| Spaulding | Sarah A. | Baptism, Mar. 27, 1858 | Died, July, 1865 |
| Spaulding | Stillman | Baptism, Mar. 27, 1858 | . |
| Mann | Lena | Baptism, Apr. 4, 1858 | . |
| Newton | Lurana L. | Baptism, Apr. 4, 1858 | Died, Dec. 23, 1863 |
| Smith | Hannah | Baptism, Apr. 4, 1858 | Letter, 1868 |
| Worcester (No.2) | Mary A. | Baptism, Apr. 4, 1858 | Letter, Feb. 1, 1879 |
| Davis | Lucy M. | Baptism, Apr. 4, 1858 | Letter, Dec. 8, 1867 |
| Fish | Martha | Baptism, Apr. 4, 1858 | Letter, Dec. 8, 1867 |
| Wilkinson | Elmira | Baptism, Apr. 4, 1858 | . |
| Wilkinson | Warren | Baptism, Apr. 4, 1858 | Letter, May 28, 1884 |
| White | Elbert | Baptism, Apr. 4, 1858 | Died, sept. 17, 1917 |
| Peters | Duane | Baptism, Apr. 18, 1858 | . |
| Carpenter | Henry | Baptism, Apr. 18, 1858 | Died |
| White | Elwin H. | Baptism, Apr. 18, 1858 | Letter, May 2, 1884 |
| Shays | Polly | Baptism, Apr. 18, 1858 | . |
| Peters | Eunice | Baptism, Apr. 18, 1858 | . |
| Mason (No.2) | Lucy | Baptism, Apr. 2, 1858 | . |
| Gartie | Mary | Letter, Sept. 15, 1858 | Died, Feb. 27, 1859 |
| Hazelton | Adelia M. | Letter, Sept. 15, 1858 | Letter, Apr. 21, 1872 |
| Newton | Arnold | Letter, Oct. 15, 1858 | Letter, Apr. 28, 1872 |
| Newton | Selinda | Baptism, Feb. 27, 1859 | Letter, Apr. 28, 1872 |
| Newton | Marcellus | Baptism, Feb. 27, 1859 | Sept. 2, 1888 |
Collection:
Cooper, William Gustin; Peck, Simon Lewis History of the Baptist Church of Ira Vermont. Rutland, Vermont:Tuttle Company, 1925.
