| Surname | Name |
Date and Manner of Reception |
When and How Dismissed |
| Carpenter | Ira | Baptism, Nov. 10, 1808 | Excluded, Nov. 30, 1809 |
| Perry | Joseph | Baptism, Nov. 10, 1808 | Excluded, Nov. 23, 1809 |
| Mason | John | Baptism, Nov. 10, 1808 | . |
| Whipple | Amy | Baptism, Nov. 20, 1808 | Excluded |
| Carpenter | Amy | Baptism, Nov. 20, 1808 | . |
| Martin | Rhoda | Baptism, Nov. 20, 1808 | . |
| Tower | Ruth | Baptism, Nov. 20, 1808 | . |
| Owen | Eliezer | Baptism, Nov. 27, 1808 | . |
| Sherman | James | Baptism, Nov. 27, 1808 | Excluded, Oct. 31, 1811 |
| Loomis | Rollin | Baptism, Nov. 27, 1808 | . |
| Ellis | Asa | Baptism, Dec. 8, 1808 | . |
| Jackman | Moses | Baptism, Dec. 8, 1808 | . |
| Collins | John | Baptism, Dec. 8, 1808 | . |
| Burlingame | James | Baptism, Dec. 8, 1808 | . |
| Ellis | Lucy | Baptism, Dec. 8, 1808 | . |
| Gill | Asenath | Baptism, Dec. 8, 1808 | . |
| Jackman | Rhoda | Baptism, Dec. 8, 1808 | . |
| Mansill | Anna | Baptism, Dec. 8, 1808 | . |
| Sherman | Ruth | Baptism, Dec. 8, 1808 | . |
| Owen | Hannah | Baptism, Dec. 8, 1808 | . |
| Shays | Mary | Baptism, Dec. 8, 1808 | . |
| Fish | Abagail | Baptism, Dec. 11, 1808 | Died |
| Carpenter | Hepzibah | Baptism, Dec. 11, 1808 | . |
| Guilford | Mary | Baptism, Dec. 11, 1808 | Letter, May 31, 1821 |
| Collins | Cynthia | Baptism, Dec. 11, 1808 | Died, 1831 |
| Fish | Preserved | Baptism, Dec. 11, 1808 | Letter, July 29, 1819 |
| Carpenter | Wilson | Baptism, Dec. 11, 1808 | . |
| Guilford | Simeon | Baptism, Dec. 11, 1808 | Letter, May 31, 1821 |
| Johnson | Zachariah | Baptism, Dec. 18, 1808 | Excluded, Jan. 29, 1820 |
| Bate | Elias | Baptism, Dec. 18, 1808 | Excluded, Mar. 18, 1819 |
| Collins | Thomas | Baptism, Dec. 18, 1808 | |
| Burlingame | Bettie | Baptism, Dec. 18, 1808 | Died, Sept. 1830 |
| Burlingame | Eunice | Baptism, Dec. 18, 1808 | Excluded, Jan. 18, 1819 |
| Burlingame | Patty | Baptism, Dec. 18, 1808 | Letter, June 30, 1827 |
| Bates | Nancy | Baptism, Dec. 18, 1808 | . |
| Carpenter | Rosamond | Baptism, Dec. 18, 1808 | . |
| Gill | Susanna | Baptism, Dec. 18, 1808 | . |
| Tower | Pracilla | Baptism, Dec. 18, 1808 | Excluded, Jan. 18, 1819 |
| Carpenter | Relief | Baptism, Dec. 18, 1808 | Died, Jan. 1842 |
| Wilmarth | Chloe | Baptism, Dec. 18, 1808 | . |
| Burlingame | Rufus | Baptism, Dec. 25, 1808 | Excluded, Aug. 11, 1813 |
| Horton | Hezekiah, Jr. | Baptism, Dec. 25, 1808 | Excluded, Jan. 26, 1826 |
| Fish | Russell (No. 1.) | Baptism, Dec. 25, 1808 | Died, Aug. 6, 1878 |
| Collins | Barton | Baptism, Dec. 25, 1808 | Letter, Oct. 30, 1831 |
| Martin | Phebe | Baptism, Dec. 25, 1808 | . |
| Burlingame | Olive | Baptism, Dec. 25, 1808 | . |
| Hays | Hannah | Baptism, Dec. 27, 1808 | Letter, Feb. 8, 1810 |
| Hedding | Eunice | Baptism, Dec. 27, 1808 | Died |
| Hayes | Johnathan | Baptism, Dec. 27, 1808 | Died |
