Graves known for sure in Sumpter Cemetery as studied by Brooks Hawley October 8, 1961.
Over 21 Years Old
D.C. Austin 1842-1900
Mattie Bailiess, guess 1874
Mayme Lee Baird 1878-1911
V. Black 1864-1900
John Beardsley 1864-1900
Ernest Wm. Beyers 1868-1904
Albert Butcher 1873-1937
Elizabeth Calhoun 1850-1907
Andrew A. Couse 1852-1910
J.P. Fain 1848-1899
Laura Bell Frodsham 1869-1903
James F. Gallagher 1833-1900
C.H. Gardner 1870-1911
Thomas Cumming Gray 1860-1909
Emma Herold Griswold 1870-1959
Nathan Hatley
Effie Hatley 1862-1951
Laura Hatley 1878-1900
Gertrude Hatley 1883-1913
Ralph Hatley 1903-1950
M.V. Hefling 1833-1908
John J. Hinton 1850-1928
Nancy C. Hinton 1854-1931
John James 1844-1901
Irat T. Jellison 1872-1901
O.W. Johnson 1898
Fred Knuth 1863-1915
Ida Knuth 1871-1930
Thomas Lavin 1874-1904
Lary E. Ledue 1856-1900
Laura Lockhart 1865-1900
Clara E. Maiwaldt 1861-1895
H.O. mcCullough 1875-1908
William McGuire 1878-1936
Lodema McVicker
Zerelda McVicker 1882-1903
O.H. Metzger 1873-1913
Nathan P. Moffet 1872-1937
Henry Newton 1835-1905
James H. Patnode 1865-1900
Mrs. Y. Raver 1839-1903
Charles Rimbol 1830-1908
Christopher R. Rowe 1865-1907
Jane Rowe 1863-1941
Chris Rowe 1891-1918
Sanford T. Rusk 1840-1904
Homer J. Sain 1860-1907
J.B. Schmidt
Nicholas L. Taliafero 1866-1950
Otie Taliafero 1876
John Torongo 1847-1912
T. Veronda
Pat Walsh 1869-1948
Thomas Dukes Webb 1828-1908
Rpse Diles Wenn 1835-1914
Davod West 1838-1924
Mary E. Taylor Whitesell 1866-1903
Nathan W. Woodruff 1821-1901
Hannah Worley 1832-1906
Albert Worley 1859-1913
Mother A.A. Wyatt 1839-1916
Joseph D. Yound 1832-1905
Mary A. Young 1855-1936
Al Young 1879-1957
Rimbol Young 1885-1954
Under 18 Years of Age
Otto Benson 1893-1896
Helen Bledsoe, 25 days 1911
Marie COnger 1893-1906
Mary Agnes Donnel 1898-1906
Mark P. Eddy 1906-1908
Robert J. Estes 1914-1915
Llewelyn Rees Evans 1893-1910
Mary C. Fisk 1888-1898
Charley A. Green 1894-1895
Frankie Gardner 1905-1909
Baby Hatley
Paul Holland, 9 months
Baby Hurt, 2 days 1900
Nellie M. Jackson 18961900
Perlie Jennings 1907-1910
Christle A. Knapp 1893-1897
Gladys Knapp, 4 months 1898
Elma S. Lippert 1899-1904
Willie Gustav Maiwaldt 1893-1895
Ella M. Maiwaldt, 2 months 1895
Baby Soards
Henry H. RObertson 1892-1904
Ethel G.l Roe 1894-1910
Gordon Starck 19061908
Harold Benard Stauffer 32 days 1911
Catherine Stewart 1912-1917
Ernest N. Sullivan 14 days 1905
Son of J.D. Swift 3 months 1903
Infant of Geo. & Evalyn Whitesell
Wesley Darr Weatherford 1892-1898
Clarence Yeager 1898-1899
99 graves listed. No doubt that many more graves not identified.
There are a few more graves known fairly sure and there are some known to be buried here but the graves are lost.
Graves in the Masonic Addition now, 1975, are: Dick Thomas 1905-1972; Bruce Boyce 1901-1975; and Crockett Wimmer 1898-1975.