Susan Brashears (formerly McCoy) and her descendants sought transfer from the Choctaw Freedmen Roll to the Choctaw Roll by Blood, citing their lineage from Oliver Stock McCoy, a recognized Choctaw citizen of mixed blood. Despite their enrollment on the 1885 Choctaw census as citizens by blood or marriage, the Dawes Commission denied their request in 1907, stating no prior application for blood enrollment had been made. Counsel argued their rightful inclusion based on the 1898 Curtis Act and precedent cases. The claimants included Susan Brashears, her children, and grandchildren, all of whom had been enrolled as freedmen.