Franklin M. Harton, Choctaw
Franklin M. Harton and multiple family members applied for Choctaw Nation citizenship by blood and intermarriage, citing their presence on the 1896 Choctaw census roll. The Dawes Commission initially denied their 1896 application, but later filings led to a 1907 decision enrolling many claimants. However, in 1907, the Department of the Interior reversed this ruling, preventing their enrollment due to a misinterpretation of legal opinions. Despite being of Choctaw descent and related to individuals on the final tribal rolls, their case remained unresolved. Legal arguments continued, asserting their right to enrollment based on ancestry and prior tribal recognition.